There are two kinds of reactions to the following statement, made by Andrea Mitchell on Morning Joe, about Elena Kagan’s qualifications to be a Supreme Court Justice:

If you can run Harvard, and the Harvard Law factory, then you can run almost anything.

Reaction number one… nodding head in silent (and unthinking) approval, and reaction number two… “What’s that again?”

Seriously? Anything? As Dean of the law school, she proved adept at fundraising, no doubt. But this qualifies her for almost anything? What about vetting mergers and acquisitions, negotiating a contract, representing someone in a divorce, not to mention running a bakery or a bank…


Continue Reading Qualified For Anything

There’s been quite a stir in the blogosphere over the Supreme Court decision in Cunningham v. California. Much of it has lamented the fact that the convicted defendant’s sentence was lowered as a result of the decision, without much thought about the principles involved.

Actually, it’s quite simple really. The Supreme Court invalidated that part of